Highlights
Evaluation of 10-year Yangtze River Fishing Ban Needs to Focus on Evolutionary Recovery
The 10-year fishing ban across the Yangtze basin is a major ecological protection project implemented by China, and an important strategic measure to promote the recuperation of the Yangtze River ecosystem. In recent years, with the continuous advancement of the fishing ban, positive changes have emerged in fish resources and the aquatic ecosystem of the Yangtze River.
Recently, a study published in Science showed that the 10-year fishing ban has significantly improved the health of fish populations in the Yangtze River, providing important scientific evidence that large-scale ecological protection measures can promote ecosystem recovery. However, a scientific question worthy of further attention is: does the recovery of fish population size and species diversity mean that their genetic diversity and long-term evolutionary potential have also recovered simultaneously?
Centering on the recent study published in Science regarding the effectiveness of the 10-year Yangtze River fishing ban, the researchers further point out, from the perspectives of conservation genomics and evolutionary biology, that the recovery of fish population size and species diversity does not mean that genetic diversity and long-term evolutionary potential have recovered simultaneously. The researchers emphasized that there may be temporal discrepancies between ecological recovery and evolutionary recovery, and therefore, it is necessary to further evaluate the impact of the fishing ban on the long-term viability of fish populations from the genetic and genomic levels.
Long-term overfishing may lead to a decline in genetic diversity, a reduction in effective population size, and a decrease in genetic connectivity among fish populations. Even if population sizes gradually recover after the fishing ban, their genetic basis and evolutionary potential to cope with future environmental changes may still require a longer time to recover, and some genetic variations may even be difficult to regain.
Therefore, when continuously evaluating the effectiveness of fishing ban across the Yangtze basin in the future, in addition to focusing on traditional ecological indicators such as population size and species diversity, genomic monitoring should be strengthened. Genetic diversity, effective population size, genetic connectivity, and adaptive genetic variation should be incorporated into the evaluation system. This will allow for a more comprehensive assessment of the Yangtze River's ecological protection effectiveness from both ecological and evolutionary perspectives, providing a scientific basis for biodiversity conservation and long-term ecological management in the Yangtze River Basin.
The above viewpoint was elaborated in a commentary titled "Ecological recovery is not evolutionary recovery," published on September 30 on the eLetters platform of the journal Science, led by the team of Academician HE Shunping from the Institute of Hydrobiology (IHB) of the Chinese Academy of Sciences.
(Editor: MA Yun)
